A Spotify Release Block Still Needs a Delivery Correction
Indonesia’s 8% Royalty Cost Cap Still Needs a Payout Trail

Indonesia’s 8% Royalty Cost Cap Still Needs a Payout Trail

Indonesia has capped LMKN’s operating fund at 8 per cent, but that is not a songwriter payout rate. Rights holders still need to trace the transfer from collector to society to member.
Indonesia’s 8% Royalty Cost Cap Still Needs a Payout Trail Indonesia’s 8% Royalty Cost Cap Still Needs a Payout Trail

Indonesia has put an 8 per cent ceiling on the national music royalty collector’s operating fund, but that figure is not a songwriter’s payout rate. The distinction matters now: on 16 November 2026, the National Collective Management Institution, or LMKN, explained the ceiling just as it was moving the first half of 2026 royalties to member societies. A writer or publisher trying to reconcile an Indonesian payment needs the actual amount collected, the amount passed to the society, the usage data attached to it and the society’s final calculation. The ceiling answers only one part of that chain.

In its 16 November explanation, LMKN said the previous framework permitted operating costs of up to 20 per cent across the collection system. Its chairman for creators, Andi Mulhanan Tombolotutu, described the old allocation as 2 per cent for LMKN, 8 per cent for a daily collection team and 10 per cent for collective management organisations. He warned against comparing the new 8 per cent ceiling with only the old 2 per cent LMKN allocation. The comparison he offered was with the former 20 per cent envelope.

What the ceiling actually covers

Article 29 of Indonesia’s Minister of Law Regulation No. 27 of 2025 permits LMKN’s creator and related-rights bodies to use an operating fund equal to 8 per cent of royalties collected each year. The text includes their operating expenses, commissioners’ salaries, supervisory support and other costs. It also says the annual spending plan must be agreed in a plenary meeting between LMKN and the collective management organisations, known locally as LMKs. That is a ceiling on a defined fund, not evidence that 8 per cent was actually deducted from every payment.

Nor does Article 29, on its own, provide a complete reconciliation from a music user’s bill to a writer’s bank account. The same regulation, in Articles 26 to 28, separates collected money into distribution, operations and reserve funds, then says LMKN distributes through LMKs. It directs the member societies to calculate payments using song usage data and report distributions back to LMKN. That sequence is why an operating-cost announcement cannot be turned into the claim that each writer now receives 92 per cent of every licence fee. Other rights holders may share the licence money, some uses may still require matching, and the writer’s own entitlement depends on the work and its registered shares.

The distinction is also relevant to a label or distributor outside Indonesia. A recording income statement and a composition royalty statement answer different questions. LMKN’s notice concerns collective management of song and related rights for commercial music uses. It is not a published change to a digital service provider’s recording payout formula. Treating it as a new per-stream rate would mix different rights and different payment routes.

A distribution announcement is not a member receipt

LMKN’s 7 November 2026 distribution notice said it had begun sending royalties for January to June 2026 to a number of LMKs. It also said it had completed calculations for a transfer, but the notice does not give a member-by-member receipt ledger.

The notice also described a 30 per cent “Unlogged Performance Allocation” in a 2026 distribution decision and said LMKN had considered responses from member societies. That percentage should not be read as 30 per cent of an individual writer’s royalty. The notice does not publish the denominator, the use categories to which the allocation applies or the amount ultimately paid to each member. Without the underlying decision and distribution schedules, its practical effect on a particular catalogue cannot be calculated from the notice alone.

Another sentence in the same announcement matters more than a headline total for anyone waiting on old money. LMKN said it would also distribute 2025 royalties that some LMKs had not previously claimed. It did not identify those societies, the repertoire involved or the dates on which members received money. A distributor or publishing administrator should therefore resist marking a missing 2025 payment as resolved merely because LMKN says a transfer to an LMK is now proceeding.

Follow the money through the society

Wahana Musik Indonesia, or WAMI, describes itself on its member-facing site as an LMK that distributes royalties to its members and to overseas partner societies, which then pay their own members. That independent description confirms the extra hand-off implicit in the regulation. For a catalogue administered from Lagos, Nairobi or Accra, the relevant check may be with the writer’s home society or publishing administrator as well as with the Indonesian society. A transfer out of LMKN is a milestone, not the end of the payment trail.

The regulation gives a practical way to frame the request. Article 28 requires an LMK’s distribution notice to LMKN to include the amount distributed, the recipients and user data by category of commercial public service. An eligible right holder or administrator can ask which period and category a statement covers, what song-use evidence was matched, which share was applied and when the LMK reported payment. Those are questions tied to fields the regulation actually names, rather than a demand for an unexplained percentage of total collections.

If the song is not yet matched to a writer, the analysis changes again. Article 31 of the 2025 regulation sets out a reserve process for royalties whose creators or related-rights owners are unknown or are not yet members of an LMK. The existence of that process is another reason a systemwide collection total cannot be equated with a same-period payout total. It also makes accurate song registration and ownership shares material to collection, not just to metadata hygiene.

For an independent catalogue entering Indonesia, the immediate job is a small reconciliation file: the composition owners and shares, the society mandate or publishing chain, the usage period and category, the LMKN-to-LMK transfer reference where available, and the member statement when it arrives. Keep the recording delivery account separate. If money is missing, that file lets the administrator locate the break: collection, transfer, matching or onward distribution.

Indonesia’s new ceiling may leave more of a collected royalty pool available for rights holders. LMKN made that case on 16 November, and the 2025 regulation confirms the ceiling. The amount any one writer receives remains a separate, testable claim. It needs a distribution statement, not a percentage in a press release.

Previous Post
Spotify Artist Profile Protection lets artists review releases linked to their profiles.

A Spotify Release Block Still Needs a Delivery Correction