An analysis of 410 songs in Spotify playlist campaigns found that most received limited plays from Spotify’s recommendations. Reaching a popularity score of 30 was associated with a higher chance of appearing in Discover Weekly, but it did not guarantee substantial listening.
The analysis used campaigns for which Spotify for Artists data was available, drawn from more than 1,900 campaigns run by Artist Influence. Spotify for Artists reports plays over a 12-month period, which can include activity before and after a campaign. The figures show an association with playlist activity, not proof that the campaigns caused recommendation plays.
Recommendation plays varied with existing audiences
Across the 410 songs, the typical song received about 13 Spotify recommendation plays for every 100 playlist plays. That ratio differed sharply by the number of plays songs received from their own fans:
- Fewer than 10,000 fan plays: about 7 recommendation plays per 100 playlist plays across 181 songs.
- 10,000 to 100,000 fan plays: about 20 per 100 across 138 songs.
- 100,000 to 1 million fan plays: about 220 per 100 across 34 songs.
- More than 1 million fan plays: about 536 per 100 across 14 songs.
The two highest-audience groups were small. Across the full set, 68% of songs received fewer than 10,000 recommendation plays over a year, including plays from Discover Weekly and Release Radar.
Some exposure was common: 95% of the campaign songs received Radio plays, 87% received Release Radar plays and 60% received Discover Weekly plays. Those appearances generally produced limited numbers for songs with smaller audiences.
What a popularity score of 30 indicates
Spotify assigns songs a popularity score from 0 to 100 that reflects recent plays relative to other music on the service. Weekly scores were tracked during campaigns for 381 songs.
About three in 10 songs that peaked below 30 received Discover Weekly plays, compared with about three in four that reached 30 to 34. Yet songs peaking at 30 or 31 had a typical total of just nine Discover Weekly plays over the year, and 14% reached at least 1,000. Among songs peaking at 36 to 39, 59% reached that mark.
Radio, Mixes and Autoplay activity rose more gradually with popularity score, without a comparable jump at 30. Release Radar, which serves an artist’s followers, reached eight or nine in 10 songs at every score level. Plays can also raise a song’s popularity score, so the data cannot establish whether crossing 30 led to Discover Weekly exposure or whether that exposure helped push the score higher.
When songs crossed the threshold
Of 260 songs that began their campaigns below 30, 57% crossed that score during the campaign. The typical crossing came 18 days in, and most occurred within four weeks. Songs starting at 25 to 29 crossed 91% of the time.
Songs that crossed had a typical total of about 25,000 playlist plays, compared with about 7,600 for those that remained below 30. In a separate group of 358 songs, the typical first playlist addition came five days into a campaign, and 69% had one within the first week.