YouTube restored musician and writer Samantha Shokin’s performance of a Bulgarian folk song about 24 hours after removing it following a copyright complaint from Media Nov Records. The dispute concerned a roughly 50-second a cappella recording that had accumulated about 125,000 views over four years.
Shokin recorded herself singing “Bre Petrunko,” a 19th-century song with no known writer, and uploaded the video to YouTube. The platform removed it in October after receiving a complaint from Media Nov, a company Shokin said she had not heard of.
The complaint and withdrawal
Media Nov describes itself as a music distribution and rights management company operating approximately 500 YouTube channels. Those channels appeared to feature mostly repetitive electronic music and imagery generated by artificial intelligence (AI). Its website refers to automated Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedowns, YouTube Content ID management and AI-powered content recognition. Records indicate the company is a little over a year old, although its website suggests a longer history.
A Media Nov spokesperson confirmed that the company withdrew its complaint minutes after Shokin supplied the requested verification. The company said it withdrew the claim because the video had generated no revenue or views, despite its reported view count of about 125,000.
Questions over the rights
The song’s age and lack of a known writer do not necessarily settle the status of every arrangement. Musician Philip Koutev popularized an arrangement in 1963, while Media Nov argued that rights in that arrangement are distinct from rights in an individual sound recording.
Shokin disputed the claim’s basis. “It’s not the arrangement that’s in question; it’s the voice and performance,” she said. Artist and copyright lawyer Alfred Steiner questioned what rights her performance could infringe if the song is a 19th-century folk work.
Steiner said submitting a takedown request for rights a claimant does not hold can create liability for damages, costs and attorney’s fees. Shokin said Media Nov had ignored her emails before responding, and described the experience as a “broken system.”