Music reproduction rights still apply when listeners stream a song, even though they no longer need to buy a physical copy. The shift from sales to access has changed how uses are recorded and payments are calculated.
From physical copies to digital access
When music was released on vinyl, cassette or compact disc (CD), manufacturers made copies for stores with the rights holders’ authorization. Those copies generated payments known as mechanical or reproduction royalties.
Brazil’s Copyright Law, Law No. 9.610/1998, Article 5, item VI, defines reproduction as copying a work or sound recording, including permanent or temporary electronic storage.
Vanisa Santiago, a copyright lawyer who works with Grupo Editorial Todamérica, has followed the industry since the era of 78-revolutions-per-minute records. “The transformation from the physical to the digital market was not a change: it was a revolution. What truly endured, and should always endure, were the fundamental concepts of authorship, artistic creation and production,” she says.
Downloads initially followed a model close to physical sales: a listener bought a track or album and stored the file on a device, with payment tied to each unit purchased. Streaming replaced ownership of a copy with access to music on demand.
“In the current subscription and streaming model, the logic shifted from ownership to access, and uses began to be recorded with each play,” says Gustavo Gonzalez, director of International Relations and Business Affairs at Abramus.
Which rights are involved
Reproduction, distribution and communication to the public were easier to identify separately in the physical market. A single stream can involve different rights, each with its own path for authorization, collection and distribution.
A musical work is the composition; a sound recording is a specific recording of it. One song can have studio, live and rerecorded versions, each with its own participants, codes and rights. “We must always look at the fundamentals: the musical work is a creation of the mind. The sound recording is a product, not a work,” Santiago says.
How publishers process payments
Publishers manage rights in the compositions and catalogs they represent. They can handle reproduction rights internally or use specialist partners. Through Abramus Digital, Abramus tracks uses reported by platforms, organizes catalog data and processes payments to publishers, which then remunerate the songwriters they represent.