NMPA Renews MLC Subpoena Request in Phono V Proceeding

The NMPA and NSAI have renewed a request for documents from the MLC’s royalty lawsuit against Spotify in the Phono V rate proceeding.
The James Madison Memorial Building in Washington, D.C., houses the U.S. Copyright Office. The James Madison Memorial Building in Washington, D.C., houses the U.S. Copyright Office.

The National Music Publishers’ Association (NMPA) and Nashville Songwriters Association International (NSAI) renewed their request on Monday to subpoena the Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC). They want documents from the MLC’s lawsuit against Spotify for the Phono V proceeding, which will set U.S. statutory mechanical royalty rates for on-demand streaming from 2028 through 2032.

Proposed streaming rates

Leading digital service providers (DSPs) submitted their Phono V proposals last month. Spotify proposed retaining the Phono IV headline rate of 15.35% of applicable service provider revenue, with “no other changes” from the earlier settlement. It called that settlement “a success for the industry” and said its bundle terms were a known, core part of the agreement.

Amazon Music proposed a 13.4% headline rate for 2028 through 2032 and sought to remove the revenue prong from bundled subscription calculations. Amazon said publishers’ response to bundling “robbed Amazon of a key benefit it expected to gain from the Phonorecords IV settlement.” The Songwriters Guild of America, Word Collections and others are seeking a simplified flat-rate mechanical royalty.

Documents sought from the MLC

The MLC’s lawsuit concerns Spotify’s reclassification of audiobook and music subscriptions as bundles. Fact discovery in that case is wrapping up. Judges at the Copyright Royalty Board (CRB) previously denied the subpoena request, before the Phono V proposals were submitted.

The renewed request seeks “[a]ll documents produced or exchanged in the Part 385 Litigation concerning the MLC’s claim that Spotify misreported and underpaid mechanical royalties owed.” The NMPA says a protective order in the lawsuit requires a subpoena to obtain restricted documents.

The NMPA and NSAI argue that the documents address how services have interpreted terms at issue in Phono V. The NMPA also says Spotify should be required to produce documents exchanged by any party or nonparty in the lawsuit, rather than choose which documents to provide.

Last month, Chief Copyright Royalty Judge Trevor Jefferson granted DSPs access to unredacted Web VI materials in the Phono V proceeding.

Previous Post
New Zealand Recording Royalties: Register Artists Before 30 January

New Zealand Recording Royalties: Register Artists Before 30 January

Next Post
Podcast follow and discovery features on YouTube, Spotify and Apple are the subject of the article.

Podcast Follows Lose Reach as Platforms Shift Discovery