Eleven European Union (EU) countries have asked the European Commission to propose legislation protecting creators’ rights when AI uses their work. For an independent artist or label, that request is a reason to review AI permissions now. It does not fill in the terms of an existing licence or identify which uses of a catalogue its owner has approved.
Separate the policy request from the permission
The countries have asked for a legislative proposal. That is a policy step, not a set of licence terms that an artist can enter into a catalogue record. An owner making a deal today still needs to decide what the other party may do with the music, which recordings or works the deal covers, and how the owner will be paid.
Start with the asset rather than the technology. A recording and the composition it contains can have different owners and different agreements. If a label controls a master but does not control every right needed for a proposed use, its own approval should describe only the rights it can grant. That makes the decision usable when a partner asks whether a particular track is cleared.
The useful question is specific: which act is being authorised? An agreement might address access to files, copying, analysis, creation of an output, or distribution of that output. Those are distinct decisions for a rightsholder to consider. A broad reference to “AI use” gives the catalogue team little help when it later has to answer whether a particular activity falls within the permission.
Make payment follow the permitted use
A permission record should pair each allowed use with its commercial term. If the parties agree to a payment, write down what triggers it, who calculates it and what information the rightsholder receives to check the calculation. If they agree to no payment for a particular use, record that decision just as clearly. Otherwise, a later income entry cannot be reliably matched to the activity that produced it.
For each proposed agreement, the artist or label should be able to answer three questions:
- Which named recordings or works, territories and time periods does the permission cover?
- Which activities does the permission allow, and who may carry them out?
- What event produces a payment, and what record will let the rightsholder verify it?
Those questions also help with catalogue valuation. A fee tied to granting access is different from a payment tied to subsequent use. Neither should be treated as recurring catalogue income without a term that actually provides for recurring payment. The forecast should follow the agreement’s trigger, rather than an expectation about what AI policy may eventually require.
Keep proof alongside the decision
Permission is easier to administer when the evidence sits with the asset record. Keep the applicable agreement, the version accepted by the other party, the covered track identifiers and the date the permission began. If a permission changes, retain the earlier version as well. That gives the person reviewing a claim or payment a way to establish which terms applied at the relevant time.
Enforcement records need the same precision. A withdrawn copyright action can end a request for records or lead to a video being restored. Those outcomes affect different parts of a rights file. A change to a document request concerns the information sought; restoration concerns the availability of the video. The rightsholder should record the actual outcome before changing a catalogue status or treating an issue as resolved.
The same discipline matters when an AI-related use is questioned. Preserve what was authorised, what use was identified, what information was requested and what response came back. Then decide whether the next step concerns permission, payment, access to records or the availability of an output. A single label such as “AI dispute” cannot tell an administrator which term to check.
Assign the next decision to the catalogue owner
IMPALA Executive Chair Helen Smith has called for stronger fraud prevention, industry coordination and safeguards for artists and labels. Coordination can improve shared practices, but each rightsholder still needs an answer for its own assets. A label receiving a request to use its catalogue should know who can approve the request and where that approval will be recorded. An artist who has delegated rights should know which agreement gives someone else that authority.
Put one decision point into the next licence review: require an explicit answer on AI use for each agreement that could cover it. Record the assets, allowed activities, payment trigger and proof needed to check performance. The call from eleven EU countries may lead to a proposal, but a rightsholder can apply those four fields to its catalogue today.