A podcast follow no longer reliably puts a new episode in front of its audience. Changes to discovery and delivery on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcasts have widened the gap between follower counts and actual listening.
YouTube prioritizes each video
YouTube, the most-used platform for podcasts, said in 2018 that recommendations drove 70% of watch time. In September, Todd Beaupré, who leads growth and discovery at YouTube, told creators that most videos in the Subscriptions feed receive a click-through rate of 10% or less. Even for a creator’s best videos, he said, “90% of the time your subscribed audience isn’t deciding to watch.”
YouTube bases recommendations mainly on how viewers respond to individual videos, including clicks, watch time and satisfaction. Since April, it has also stopped sending phone alerts to subscribers who selected “All” notifications if they have not watched a channel in about a month.
Spotify places followed shows in a separate tab while its Home screen presents recommendations. A Spotify follow has never automatically downloaded new episodes as a Really Simple Syndication (RSS) subscription could.
Apple adjusts episode delivery
Apple Podcasts still generally downloads new episodes for followers, but it stops doing so for those who have drifted away. In 2021, Apple changed “Subscribe” to “Follow” in iOS 14.5 ahead of its paid podcast subscriptions launch.
Follows still affect visibility on Apple. The company says that more followers and engagement can raise a show’s chart position. Some publishers have bought follows through mobile game ads at $5 apiece, prompting Bumper’s Dan Misener to distinguish the two measures: “You can buy traffic. You can’t buy audience.”
Social feeds show the wider shift
TikTok built its For You feed around recommendations from accounts a user may never have followed. Instagram added Reels, YouTube added Shorts, and Facebook and X shifted their feeds toward recommended posts.
- An analysis by quso.ai of about 31,000 creator posts found that TikTok’s For You feed delivered 85% of views, compared with 0.3% from its Following feed.
- Recommended posts from accounts users did not follow accounted for about 15% of the Facebook feed in 2022 and about 40% of what people saw on Instagram a year later.
- A Meta chart presented at the Federal Trade Commission antitrust trial showed time spent on friends’ posts falling to 7% on Instagram.
Patreon CEO Jack Conte has described creators struggling to reach communities they spent years building. Instagram has since expanded “Your Algorithm,” which lets users choose topics they want to see more or less often. Instagram head Adam Mosseri said following accounts “used to be a meaningful tool people had for shaping their own experience,” but that it “quietly stopped working.”