An AI Licence Needs Its Own Catalogue Ledger

A streaming statement cannot tell a label what an AI company was allowed to use. Record the permission, the agreed payment and the work behind each receipt in a separate catalogue ledger.
A proposal from 11 EU countries calls for stronger copyright protections in the use of creative work by AI. A proposal from 11 EU countries calls for stronger copyright protections in the use of creative work by AI.

An AI company’s use of a catalogue depends on what the artist or label authorised and what payment, if any, they agreed. That creates a recordkeeping problem: an incoming payment identifies neither the full scope of the permission nor which rights holder should receive it. Keep the permission and its payment in a ledger that can be read alongside, but separately from, ordinary music royalty statements.

Start with the permission

A request for European Union legislation does not set an AI company’s terms for using a catalogue. The operative document for a catalogue owner is therefore the record of the authorisation it gave. Before accepting a payment as income from a particular work, the artist or label needs to connect that work to the permission and the agreed payment.

That connection matters at both ends of a deal. The permission tells the catalogue owner which use it approved. The payment record tells the person allocating income what the company agreed to pay for that approval. A bank receipt alone cannot answer either question. Nor does a list of works, by itself, show what use was authorised. Keep the two records together so that the amount received can be checked against the rights actually granted.

For a catalogue with multiple works, make each entry specific enough to answer a practical question: does this receipt belong to this work under this authorisation? If the answer requires someone to reconstruct a conversation later, the ledger is missing a decision the parties needed to record when they made it. This follows directly from the need for a clear record of what was authorised and what payment was agreed, if any.

Keep the income paths distinct

Catalogue income already travels through different records. For Jamaican songwriter royalties, the International Standard Recording Code (ISRC), writer shares and usage records matter to the work data held by the Jamaica Association of Composers, Authors and Publishers (JACAP). The same account distinguishes composition income from a distributor’s master-side income. Those are different questions from whether an AI company obtained permission to use a catalogue.

That distinction changes how a label should read a statement. A distributor’s master receipt does not, on its own, establish a songwriter’s composition balance. A JACAP balance does not document an AI company’s permission. And an AI payment cannot be allocated reliably from a streaming statement unless the permission and payment record identify the works and rights behind it. Each income path needs the document that explains why money is due, plus the data needed to assign it to the right party.

Use separate ledger lines for the AI permission, composition royalties and master income. Where the same work appears in all three, link the entries by work rather than combining their balances. This gives an artist or label a way to reconcile total catalogue receipts while preserving the reason for each receipt. It also prevents a missing royalty payment from being mistaken for a missing AI payment, or the reverse.

A delayed royalty is a different question

JACAP’s $500 payout threshold can delay Jamaican songwriter royalties, and balances below the threshold carry forward. Missing work data can also delay payment. Those two situations call for different checks: inspect the work’s identifying and writer information when data is missing, and inspect the carried balance when the threshold has not been reached.

Neither check determines what an AI company owes. That obligation comes from the use the catalogue owner authorised and the payment the parties agreed. Putting the AI receipt into the same unexplained balance as a society royalty would hide the mechanism behind both amounts. It would also make a threshold appear relevant to a payment governed by a separate agreement.

Make each receipt answerable

A workable catalogue ledger needs a short set of fields for every income claim:

For an independent artist or label, the immediate decision is whether every AI-related receipt can be matched to an authorisation and an agreed payment. If it cannot, resolve that match before allocating the money across the catalogue. Then reconcile composition and master income through their own records. The $500 threshold is a useful reminder that an unpaid balance and an unauthorised use are different problems, with different documents needed to settle them.

Previous Post
A proposal from 11 EU countries calls for stronger copyright protections in the use of creative work by AI.

Write the AI Use Terms Before the Law Arrives

Next Post
Vietnam Cover Releases: Allow 7 or 14 Days for Song Clearance

A Cover Licence Answers Permission, Not Payment